Legal Judgments in the Japanese Judicial System251

判決

Hanrei (判決) is a Japanese legal term that refers to judicial decisions, particularly those of the Supreme Court of Japan. These decisions are considered authoritative sources of law and are binding on lower courts. The doctrine of stare decisis, which means "to stand by things decided," is not strictly followed in Japan, but the Supreme Court's decisions are highly persuasive and are generally followed by lower courts.

Hanrei are published in official reports and are widely available to legal professionals and the public. They are often cited in legal arguments and are an important source of information about the interpretation of laws and the development of legal principles.

Types of Hanrei

There are two main types of hanrei:
1. Precedential decisions: These are decisions that are binding on lower courts and must be followed in subsequent cases involving similar facts and legal issues.

2. Persuasive decisions: These are decisions that are not binding on lower courts but are highly persuasive and are often followed by lower courts when deciding similar cases.

The Role of Hanrei in the Japanese Legal System

Hanrei play a significant role in the Japanese legal system. They provide guidance to lower courts on how to interpret and apply laws, and they help to ensure that similar cases are treated similarly. Hanrei also contribute to the development of legal principles and doctrines over time.

The Supreme Court of Japan has the authority to overturn its own previous decisions, but it does so rarely. This is because the Court generally follows the principle of stare decisis and believes that it is important to maintain stability and predictability in the law.

Criticism of Hanrei

The use of hanrei in the Japanese legal system has been criticized by some scholars. Critics argue that the emphasis on precedent can lead to inflexibility and a lack of innovation in the law. They also argue that hanrei can be difficult to understand and apply, particularly for non-legal professionals.

Despite these criticisms, hanrei remain an important part of the Japanese legal system. They provide valuable guidance to lower courts and help to ensure consistency and predictability in the law.

Conclusion

Hanrei are judicial decisions that play a significant role in the Japanese legal system. They provide guidance to lower courts on how to interpret and apply laws, and they help to ensure that similar cases are treated similarly. Hanrei also contribute to the development of legal principles and doctrines over time.

2024-12-12

Previous：The Art of Pronouncing Korean: A Guide to Perfecting Your Korean Pronunciation

Next：What Do Japanese Loanwords Do in English?